FDM and SLS both build plastic parts layer by layer, but they put a part’s weak plane in different places and spend money in different places. Picking the wrong one costs either money or part performance. Three factors settle most decisions: the direction of the load the part has to survive, how many identical parts you need, and how much equipment and powder handling your shop can take on.
FDM is the low-cost, flexible process for prototypes, fixtures, large parts and parts that need a specific filament, a color or two materials at once. SLS is the production process for functional nylon and TPU parts that are loaded in more than one direction, complex inside, or needed by the dozen. The machine and material figures below are for the E3, Pro3 HS and RMF500 FDM printers and the RMS220 SLS printer.
What FDM and SLS are
Fused deposition modeling (FDM), also called fused filament fabrication (FFF), is a 3D printing process in which a heated nozzle melts a plastic filament and lays it down bead by bead on a build plate. Each bead fuses to the layer below with its own heat. Overhangs more than about 45° from vertical need printed supports.
Selective laser sintering (SLS) is a 3D printing process in which a laser fuses each part’s cross-section into a thin layer of polymer powder, usually a nylon, held just below its melting point. The unfused powder around the parts holds them in place, so nothing is printed as support and parts can be stacked through the whole build volume instead of laid out on a plate.
The difference in how the material is joined, a bead welded onto a layer that has already cooled versus powder fused into a bed that is still hot, explains most of what follows.
SLS vs FDM at a glance
| Factor | FDM | SLS |
|---|---|---|
| How it builds | A nozzle extrudes molten filament, one bead at a time | A laser fuses each part’s cross-section in a heated powder bed |
| Feedstock | 1.75 mm filament on spools | Nylon or TPU powder, fresh powder blended with recovered powder |
| Supports | Needed for steep overhangs, removed by hand or dissolved | None, the unfused powder holds the part |
| Weak direction | Between layers: Z strength is 52% of in-layer strength in PA12 CF+ | Close to none: Z strength is 98% of X strength in PA12 |
| Layer height | 0.1–0.3 mm recommended with a 0.4 mm nozzle | 0.1–0.2 mm recommended (0.05–0.40 mm range) |
| Heat resistance (HDT at 1.8 MPa) | Up to 104°C (219°F) in PA12 CF+ | 45–51°C (113–124°F) in unfilled PA12 and PA NEXT |
| Surface as printed | Layer lines on walls, top faces under 2 µm Ra with ironing | Matte, fine grain, the same on every face |
| Materials | PLA, ABS, ASA, PETG, PC, TPU, carbon- and glass-filled PPA and PET, PA12 CF+, PPS CF, ESD PETG, soluble supports | PA12, PA11, PA NEXT, glass-bead-filled PA12 and PA NEXT, TPU 86A and 90A |
| Color | Any filament color, two colors in one part with dual extrusion | Black, TPU 86A also in white, nylon dyeable after blasting |
| Largest part | 500 × 500 × 500 mm (19.7 in cube) on the RMF500 | 220 × 220 × 350 mm (8.7 × 8.7 × 13.8 in) on the RMS220 |
| How batches are made | Parts laid out on one plate, IDEX printers copy two at once | Parts nested in 3D through the whole bed |
| First part in hand | When the print ends | After printing plus about 12 hours of cooling (6–16 by material), then depowdering |
| Post-processing | Support removal, optional annealing or sanding | Depowdering and bead blasting |
| Facility | Bench and single-phase power (RMF500: 3-phase 380 V) | Compressed air, dust control, powder handling area, room at 15–30°C and 50% RH or less |
| Entry price | E3 from $2,499 | RMS220 from $34,999 with one build unit |
| Best fit | Prototypes, jigs and fixtures, large parts, heat-exposed parts, multi-material parts, low counts | Functional nylon and TPU parts, complex internal geometry, batches of small and mid-size parts |
Part strength and direction of load
Printed parts rarely fail because the polymer is too weak. They fail along their weakest plane, and FDM and SLS put that plane in different places.
Why FDM parts are weaker between layers
An FDM bead is laid on a layer that has already cooled. The hot bead reheats the surface below it for a fraction of a second, long enough to bond but not long enough for the polymer chains on both sides to intermix fully. The interface ends up weaker than the bead, so a bracket loaded across its layers, or a pipe under internal pressure, tends to split along a layer line.
Three things raise that bond strength: a warm, enclosed build chamber, a layer time short enough that the surface is still warm when the next bead arrives, and annealing after printing. The PA12 CF+ datasheet, for example, calls for 8 to 12 hours at 80–100°C (176–212°F), with up to 0.4% shrinkage in Z afterward, which a fixture designer has to allow for.
Why SLS parts are close to equal in every direction
In SLS the whole powder bed sits a few degrees below the polymer’s melting point, and the laser adds only the last increment of energy. Each new layer melts into a layer that is still hot, and the finished build cools and crystallizes as one block. Every region of the part shares the same thermal history, so its properties come out close to equal in X, Y and Z.
The same mechanism explains two SLS traits covered later: a build needs hours to cool before the parts come out, and thin flat parts warp if they cool unevenly.
Anisotropy in numbers
The datasheets show where each process is strong. All values are typical ISO 527 results on test bars, not guaranteed values for a specific part.
| Property | SLS PA12 (RMS220) | SLS PA NEXT (RMS220) | FDM PA12 CF+ |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tensile strength along layers (X or XY) | 50 MPa (7,250 psi) | 45 MPa (6,530 psi) | 86 MPa (12,470 psi) |
| Tensile strength across layers (Z) | 49 MPa (7,110 psi) | 45 MPa (6,530 psi) | 44.7 MPa (6,480 psi) |
| Z strength as a share of in-layer strength | 98% | 100% | 52% |
| Elongation at break, in-layer / Z | 9% / 6% | 36% / 30% | 2.8% / 1.9% |
| Tensile modulus, in-layer | 1,791 MPa | 1,590 MPa | 4,736 MPa |
| Heat deflection temperature at 1.8 MPa | 51°C (124°F) | 45–48°C (113–118°F) | 104°C (219°F) |
Read the table by load direction. Along its layers the carbon-fiber FDM part is about 1.7 times as strong and 2.6 times as stiff as SLS PA12, and it keeps its shape under load to about twice the temperature. Across its layers it is about 9% weaker than SLS PA12 and stretches less than 2% before it breaks.
That makes the split practical. For a fixture with a known, one-direction load, orient the FDM part so the load runs along the layers, raise the wall count and use a fiber-filled grade such as PPA CF or PA12 CF+. The result is often stiffer and stronger than the SLS alternative. For snap fits, living hinges, clips, pressure-bearing housings and parts that get dropped, the load direction is unknown or changes, and a part that stretches 30% in Z, as PA NEXT does, survives where a part that stretches 2% cracks.
Kinboshi ran this comparison on its own parts before adding SLS, with a drop test and a 1 MPa (145 psi) pressure test. The case is described below.
Design freedom, supports and design rules
Supports cost material, print time and labor, and they limit what you can design in the first place.
On a single-extruder FDM printer the support is printed in the part material and snapped or cut away afterward. It leaves marks and can’t be reached inside closed channels. On dual-extrusion printers such as the E3 and Pro3 HS, the second nozzle prints dissolvable PVA+ or a dedicated breakaway support filament, which makes internal features possible at the cost of extra material and a post-processing step.
SLS needs no supports. Internal ducts, enclosed lattices, hinges printed already assembled and parts nested inside other parts all print in one build. The trade is that every cavity has to let the powder out, so enclosed volumes need escape holes.
If a part needs supports where you can’t reach to remove them, it is an SLS part. A closed hollow part with no way for powder to escape is an FDM part, or a design to change.
Design rules for each process
| Rule | FDM (0.4 mm nozzle) | SLS (RMS220) |
|---|---|---|
| Thinnest wall | About 0.8 mm (two line widths) for a solid wall | 0.5 mm in PA11 with thin-wall mode |
| Overhangs | More than about 45° from vertical need support | No limit, the powder holds the part |
| Internal channels | Need soluble support, or must be self-supporting | Print freely, with openings to clear the powder |
| Enclosed hollow volumes | Print as closed shells with infill | Need two or more escape holes so trapped powder can be removed |
| Holes | Vertical holes print undersized, drill or ream to size | Shrinkage compensated by scaling, verify on a sample |
| Placement | Anywhere on the plate | At least 5 mm from bed edges, 10 mm for demanding parts |
| Strength orientation | Run the main load along the layers | No orientation rule for strength |
| Moving assemblies | Print as separate parts, or in place with soluble support | Hinges and assemblies print in place with clearance |
Treat these as starting points, and confirm thin walls and clearances on a test print in the material you will use.
Materials
No print setting makes up for the wrong polymer, and the two processes draw from very different material lists.
FDM has the wider list. The E3 prints PLA, ABS, ASA, PETG, PC and TPU 95A, carbon- and glass-filled PPA and PET, PA12 CF+ and PPS CF with the composite filament print head, an ESD-safe PETG, and soluble PVA+ and breakaway support filaments. With the Flexible Filament Auxiliary Feeder it prints TPU and TPE from 95A down to 80A. Any filament color is available, and dual extrusion puts two colors or two materials in one part.
The RMS220 runs a shorter list built around functional nylons and elastomers:
- PA12, a general-purpose nylon with good dimensional stability and low moisture uptake.
- PA11, tougher and better at fine detail, used for clips, snap fits and connectors.
- PA NEXT, a toughened nylon that stretches 30–36% before breaking, four to five times as far as PA12, with the most uniform properties of the range and a smoother finish after blasting. It is the grade we recommend over PA12 for most new functional parts.
- PA12 GB and PA NEXT GB, filled with glass beads for stiffness and dimensional stability. PA12 GB also resists heat better than plain PA12.
- TPU 86A (black or white) and TPU 90A, flexible elastomers for insoles, grippers, padding and protective parts.
Selected third-party powders run under the Open Material Program, and a fully open material license is available. For a full comparison of the powders, see How to choose a material for SLS 3D printing.
One limit matters for fixtures. Unfilled PA12 and PA NEXT deflect under a 1.8 MPa load at 45–51°C (113–124°F), while PA12 CF+ holds to 104°C (219°F). A fixture that sits next to a curing oven or a hot process is an FDM part.
If you need a specific polymer family, a carbon-fiber stiffness-to-weight ratio, heat resistance, an ESD grade or a color, start with FDM. If you need tough nylon with the same properties in every direction, or a TPU part that flexes the same way in every direction, start with SLS.
Moisture and conditioning
Nylon absorbs water from the air, as filament and as powder. Moisture in filament turns to steam in the nozzle and prints porous, weak, stringy parts, which is why the E3 keeps both spools in desiccant storage slots and the RMF500 ships with dry storage bags. SLS powder is stored sealed, and the RMS220 is specified for a room at 15–30°C (59–86°F) and no more than 50% relative humidity.
Printed nylon keeps exchanging moisture with the room after it leaves the printer, so measure critical dimensions after parts have settled in the environment they will work in.
Dimensional accuracy and surface finish
Accuracy decides whether a part goes straight into an assembly or needs a fit check and rework first, so it belongs in the decision before throughput and cost.
FDM accuracy is set by the motion system in X and Y and by layer height in Z, where it shows as steps on curved and sloped faces. Vertical holes print slightly undersized and are usually drilled or reamed to size, and the first layers can flare outward where they meet the plate. Annealed composites shrink a little in Z, as noted above.
FDM surfaces depend on the face. Top faces can be very smooth: the E3 reaches a roughness under 2 µm Ra with Hyper Speed PLA Pro and ironing enabled. Side walls show layer lines, and faces printed over supports show support marks.
The RMS220’s reference accuracy is ±0.2 mm (±0.008 in). What a given part holds depends on material, geometry, packing and position in the bed. TPU moves more than PA11. The center of the bed is more thermally stable than the corners, so keep parts at least 5 mm from the edges, and 10 mm for demanding parts. Thin flat plates warp if they cool unevenly, so tilt them in the bed and don’t pack them tightly. SLS parts shrink as they cool, and the build file is scaled to compensate.
SLS surfaces are matte with a fine grain and look the same on every face, because there is no plate side and no support side. Bead blasting on the B520 station cleans and evens the surface, and blasted PA NEXT is usually smooth enough for a prototype or fit check without dyeing or coating.
FDM gives the smoother single face, and SLS gives the more uniform part. For either process, the reliable check is a sample of your own part, measured.
Part size
A part that doesn’t fit the printer has to be split and bonded, which adds labor and puts a joint where the part may be weakest.
The FDM range covers 330 × 240 × 240 mm (13 × 9.4 × 9.4 in) on the E3, 300 × 300 × 300 mm (11.8 in cube) on the Pro3 HS, 300 × 300 × 605 mm (11.8 × 11.8 × 23.8 in) on the Pro3 Plus HS, and 500 × 500 × 500 mm (19.7 in cube) on the RMF500, which fits a part up to 707 mm (27.8 in) long laid diagonally. The RMS220 builds to 220 × 220 × 350 mm (8.7 × 8.7 × 13.8 in), a volume of 17 L.
SLS chambers are smaller because the whole powder bed has to be held at an even temperature just below melting, and that gets harder and more expensive as the bed grows. For a single large part, such as a 600 mm (23.6 in) housing on a Pro3 Plus HS or a half-meter fixture base on an RMF500, FDM is the only option of the two that avoids splitting the part.
Throughput, batch size and lead time
Throughput decides cost per part, because a printer’s fixed costs are shared across every part it makes in a run.
How each process scales
FDM prints on a flat plate one bead at a time, so a batch is limited by plate area. The Pro3 HS prints at 300 mm/s as standard and runs Hyper Core composites at 200–300 mm/s, and its automatic filament switching across two 2.5 kg (5.5 lb) spools lets a long batch run unattended. The E3 and RMF500 are IDEX (independent dual extruder) printers, with two heads that print two identical or mirrored parts at once, which doubles output for parts that fit half the plate. Beyond that, more output means more printers, each one loaded, unloaded and checked.
SLS nests parts in three dimensions through the whole bed, so one build can hold hundreds of small parts. Reference builds on the RMS220:
| Part | Material | Part size (mm) | Parts per build | Print time | Cost per part |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cable clip | PA11 | 20 × 69 × 46 | 192 | 47 min | $1.00 |
| Insole | TPU 90A | 94 × 283 × 23 | 18 | 8 h 40 min | $2.80 |
| Ventilation duct | PA NEXT GB | 203 × 26 × 165 | 18 | 6 h 33 min | $5.00 |
| Shunt intake manifold | PA12 GB | 180 × 116 × 160 | 4 | 2 h 23 min | $20.70 |
| Helmet lining | TPU 86A white | 194 × 135 × 268 | 1 | 12 h 16 min | $33.00 |
Cost per finished part includes material, labor, energy, machine depreciation and key consumables, and moves with material price, refresh rate, packing density and post-processing. One insole of that size fits two to a plate on an E3, against 18 per SLS build. The helmet lining shows the other end of the range: a single large part fills a build, prints for more than 12 hours and costs $33.
Throughput in one unit
Speeds in mm/s and L/h can’t be compared directly, so convert both to solid part volume per hour.
The RMS220 sinters 2.2 L of powder bed per hour at 20% packing density. Packing density is the weight of the sintered parts as a share of all the powder in the build. PA12 powder has a bulk density of 0.521 g/cm³ and printed PA12 a density of 1.024 g/cm³, so:
2.2 L/h × 0.521 kg/L × 0.20 = 0.23 kg (0.5 lb) of parts per hour, about 224 cm³ (13.7 in³) of solid nylon.
Over a full day, with warm-up and build changes, the rated output is 3.5 kg (7.7 lb) of PA12 parts.
The E3’s maximum volumetric speed is 16 mm³/s per head, or 58 cm³ (3.5 in³) per hour. Two heads in duplication mode reach about 115 cm³ (7 in³) per hour, and that is a ceiling, since acceleration, travel moves and thin perimeters keep the average below it.
At peak, one RMS220 deposits about twice the solid volume of an E3 running both heads at full speed. FDM parts are rarely printed solid, though, so the volume a part needs depends on its infill. The useful comparison is parts per day on your own part, which a sample print on each process gives you.
Where lead time goes
FDM lead time is print time. SLS lead time is print time plus cooling: after printing, the build unit leaves the printer and cools for about 12 hours, 6 to 16 depending on material, before the parts can be depowdered.
The cable clip build prints in 47 minutes, so printing is only about 5–12% of the time from start to depowdering. Adding parts to an SLS build barely changes when they arrive, which is why SLS rewards batching and why one urgent part is usually faster on an FDM printer. A second build unit lets the printer start the next job while the last one cools, so cooling costs lead time but not printer time.
Cost: equipment, cost per part and powder
SLS spends most of its money before the first part, on the printer, powder handling and post-processing equipment. FDM spends it on every part, in print hours, supports and operator time.
Equipment
The E3 starts at $2,499 and the RMF500 at $69,999. The RMS220 with one build unit is $34,999, and the Standard Package, which adds the C220-P cleaning station, is $44,998. A production cell typically adds a second build unit, the B520 blasting station, an industrial vacuum or dust-control unit and compressed air, plus installation and training, all quoted for the site.
The RMS220 with one build unit costs as much as fourteen E3 printers. For a shop printing a handful of parts a week, that alone settles the question in favor of FDM.
Cost per part
SLS cost per part falls as builds fill. The reference costs above, from about $1.00 for a cable clip at 192 per build to $20.70 for an intake manifold at 4 per build, hold only when builds are full, so SLS rewards a steady flow of parts.
FDM cost per part is mostly filament and printer time, and standard filament is cheap. Two costs are easy to miss: support material and the labor to remove it, and the labor of loading, unloading and checking every plate. For one-offs, prototypes and low counts, FDM is cheaper. SLS becomes cheaper per finished part when the same printer runs full builds of functional parts week after week.
Powder refresh rate and packing density
Unsintered SLS powder is recovered and reused, but heat ages it, so each build mixes recovered powder with a share of fresh powder. That share is the refresh rate, and it sets how much recovered powder you can put back into production.
| Powder | Refresh rate in nitrogen | Refresh rate in air |
|---|---|---|
| PA12 | 30% | 50% |
| PA11 | 30% | 50% |
| PA NEXT and PA NEXT GB | 20% | 50% |
| TPU | About 20% |
The balance works like this. After a build, all the powder that did not become parts is recovered, but the next build can take back only the share that the refresh rate leaves for recovered powder. When packing density is lower than the refresh rate, recovered powder accumulates faster than it can be used.
Take a 10 kg (22 lb) PA12 build in nitrogen, packed at 15%. It makes 1.5 kg of parts and leaves 8.5 kg of recovered powder. The next 10 kg build takes 7 kg of it plus 3 kg of fresh powder, so 1.5 kg of recovered powder is left over: about 1 kg of surplus for every kg of parts. The same build in PA NEXT takes back 8 kg, leaving about 0.33 kg of surplus per kg of parts, and at 20% packing it uses all of it. The example ignores the small amount of powder lost in depowdering and sieving.
Packing has a ceiling as well as a floor. The recommended range is 10–20% by weight, densely packed solid parts can overheat the build and fail, and packing above 40% is not recommended. Surplus powder either waits for a densely packed build or leaves the process, and either way it belongs in your cost per part.
Atmosphere changes the numbers too. The RMS220 makes its own nitrogen from compressed air, which covers common nitrogen workflows. Some PA11 processes need oxygen held below 2%, which can call for an external nitrogen supply of more than 99.9% purity.
When SLS pays off
The break-even point is the monthly volume at which per-part savings cover the cell’s fixed cost:
Break-even parts per month = monthly fixed cost of the SLS cell ÷ (FDM cost per part − SLS variable cost per part)
SLS variable cost here means powder, energy and labor, without depreciation. As an illustration, spreading the $44,998 Standard Package over five years gives about $750 a month before financing and before the rest of the cell. If a part costs $3 less on SLS than on FDM once supports and plate handling are counted, 250 parts a month cover that $750. Replace each number with your own quote, labor rate and parts.
Facility, workflow and safety
A process the team can’t run reliably costs more in failed builds and idle time than it saves.
An E3 or Pro3 HS sits on a bench and runs on standard single-phase power, 100–240 V. Both filter their exhaust through a HEPA and activated-charcoal filter, are rated for rooms at 15–30°C (59–86°F), and can be run by most of a team after short training. The RMF500 is the exception: a 790 kg (1,742 lb) floor-standing machine that needs 3-phase 380 V, 25 A power and its own floor space.
An SLS printer is the center of a small production cell. The RMS220 itself takes 0.58 m² (6.2 ft²) of floor and needs compressed air for its built-in nitrogen generator. Around it you need:
- a room held at 15–30°C (59–86°F) and no more than 50% relative humidity
- compressed air for the B520 blasting station, more than 360 SLPM (12.7 SCFM) at 6 bar from a 6–8 bar (87–116 psi) supply
- an industrial vacuum or dust-control unit
- a powder storage and sieving area
- a UPS where mains power is unstable
- operators trained to follow a consistent powder refresh and cleaning routine
Changing powder in the printer takes about 45 minutes, which is quick for SLS but slower than swapping a spool. Keep one C220-P cleaning station per material so recovered powders don’t cross-contaminate.
Both processes run on the same software. ideaMaker slices FDM and SLS jobs, and RaiseCloud manages queues and printer status across both, so a team that adds an RMS220 to an FDM fleet keeps one workflow.
Safety
Nylon and TPU powders are fine particulates. Handle them with gloves, eye protection and a dust mask or respirator, clean up with a vacuum rated for combustible dust rather than compressed air or a broom, and keep the powder area free of ignition sources. The safety data sheet for each powder sets the exact requirements.
FDM printing releases ultrafine particles and fumes, more with ABS, ASA and PC than with PLA, which is why printers in shared rooms should be enclosed and filtered.
Which process fits which application
The application decides the process more reliably than any general rule.
| Application | Better fit | Printer and material | Why |
|---|---|---|---|
| Concept and look-alike models | FDM | E3 or Pro3 HS in PLA | Cheapest and fastest single part, any color |
| Fit-check prototypes of housings | FDM | Pro3 HS in PLA or ABS | Quick reprints after each design change |
| Functional prototypes with snap fits or hinges | SLS | RMS220 in PA11 or PA NEXT | Same strength in every direction, hinges print assembled |
| Assembly jigs and drilling fixtures | FDM | Pro3 HS in PPA CF or ABS CF | Stiff composites, known load direction, one-off parts |
| Fixtures exposed to heat | FDM | E3 or RMF500 in PA12 CF+ | Holds shape to 104°C (219°F) under load |
| Large fixtures, check gauges and tooling bases | FDM | RMF500 in Hyper Core ABS CF15 or PPA CF25 | The only process of the two that fits half-meter parts |
| Batches of clips, brackets and holders | SLS | RMS220 in PA11 or PA NEXT | 192 clips per build at about $1 each |
| Ducts and parts with internal channels | SLS | RMS220 in PA NEXT GB | No supports to trap inside the part |
| Pressure-bearing or drop-exposed parts | SLS | RMS220 in PA12 or PA NEXT | No weak layer plane, 3 mm wall held 1 MPa at Kinboshi |
| Insoles and orthotic parts in volume | SLS | RMS220 in TPU 86A or 90A | 18 insoles per build, the same flex in every direction |
| One-off soft grippers and flexible prototypes | FDM | E3 with the flexible feeder, TPU 80A to 95A | No powder setup for a single part |
| ESD-safe fixtures for electronics | FDM | E3 or Pro3 HS in PETG ESD | ESD grade available as filament |
| Two-material or two-color parts | FDM | E3 or Pro3 HS | Dual extrusion, IDEX handles different print temperatures |
| Mixed R&D and production in one team | Both | E3 or Pro3 HS plus RMS220 | FDM for iteration, SLS for functional batches |
How Kinboshi runs both processes
Kinboshi is a Japanese manufacturer of safety, healthcare and industrial products, founded in 1948, with about 190 employees. It has run Raise3D Pro series FDM printers since 2021 for rapid prototyping, small trial batches and material testing in ABS, PETG and carbon-fiber filaments, across three R&D and production sites that turn ordered parts around the same day.
As its use grew, some functional parts hit FDM’s limits: weak Z-axis bonding, supports that were hard to remove, and limits on design freedom and fine detail. Kinboshi had used powder-bed printers from other brands for those parts, and set two requirements for a replacement: lower anisotropy and lower printing cost.
Before buying an RMS220, Kinboshi ran three tests. A large part that tends to warp checked accuracy and deformation. A part dropped from its working height came through without breaking. A pipe part with 3 mm (0.12 in) walls held 1 MPa (145 psi) of water pressure without leaking. The RMS220 was installed in October 2025.
Kinboshi did not replace FDM. The Pro series printers still handle prototyping, pilot runs and low-cost parts, and the RMS220 takes the medium batches where strength, flexibility and support-free geometry matter. Both run through ideaMaker and RaiseCloud, so the team kept one workflow. The full case is in FDM vs SLS: How Kinboshi uses the Pro2 and RMS220.
Frequently asked questions
Is SLS stronger than FDM?
It depends on the load direction. SLS PA12 is close to equally strong in every direction, at 49–50 MPa (7,110–7,250 psi). Carbon-fiber FDM is stronger along its layers, 86 MPa (12,470 psi) in PA12 CF+, and weaker across them, at 44.7 MPa (6,480 psi). For loads in an unknown or changing direction, SLS is the safer choice. For a known load you can orient the part around, FDM often performs better.
Can FDM nylon replace SLS nylon?
For stiff fixtures with a known load, often yes, and it can be the better part: PA12 CF+ is about 1.7 times as strong along its layers as SLS PA12 and holds its shape to 104°C (219°F) under load. For snap fits, clips and parts that get dropped, no. Across its layers PA12 CF+ stretches 1.9% before breaking, against 6% for SLS PA12 and 30% for PA NEXT.
How much SLS powder is wasted?
Unsintered powder is recovered and blended with fresh powder for the next build, so waste depends on packing density and refresh rate. When builds are packed at or above the refresh rate, almost all recovered powder goes back into production. A PA12 build packed at 15% in nitrogen leaves about 1 kg of surplus recovered powder per kg of parts. PA NEXT at the same packing leaves about a third of that.
Can SLS parts hold water or air pressure?
Yes, with walls sized for it. Kinboshi’s pipe part with 3 mm (0.12 in) walls held 1 MPa (145 psi) of water pressure without leaking. Sintered nylon has some porosity, so test thin walls and gas-tight parts on a sample before production. FDM parts can leak along layer seams, so pressure-bearing FDM parts need thick walls and tuned print settings.
Do SLS parts come in colors?
Most RMS220 powders print black, and TPU 86A also comes in white. Nylon parts can be dyed after bead blasting. If a part needs a specific color straight off the printer, or two colors in one part, FDM covers any filament color, and dual extrusion prints two colors or two materials together.
How many identical parts make SLS worth it?
There is no fixed number, because it depends on part size and on what each part costs you on FDM. The signal is a steady flow that keeps builds full: the same functional part printed dozens of times a month, or nylon parts sent to a service bureau every week. The break-even formula in the cost section turns that into a monthly figure for your parts.
Where does resin printing fit?
Resin (DLP) printers such as the DF2+ suit small parts that need fine detail and a smooth surface straight off the printer. Resin parts are a different material class from nylon and TPU, so for functional nylon and TPU parts the choice is usually between FDM and SLS.
Conclusion
FDM and SLS cover different parts of the same job. FDM is the low-cost process for prototypes, fixtures, large parts, heat-exposed parts and anything that needs a specific filament, a color or two materials at once. SLS is the production process for nylon and TPU parts that are loaded in more than one direction, have closed internal features, or are needed by the dozen.
If most of your parts are one-offs and fixtures, a pair of E3 or Pro3 HS printers covers them for a fraction of the cost of an SLS cell. If you print the same functional nylon part dozens of times a month on FDM plates, fight supports inside closed channels, or send nylon parts to a service bureau every week, run the break-even calculation above with your own numbers. That is the workload the RMS220 is built for.
Our application engineers can print sample parts on both processes from your CAD files, so you can compare strength, finish and cost on your own parts before deciding. Request sample parts or a demo.